The Anwar Ibrahim sodomy trial resumed today with renewed vigour in the defence following yesterday's success in having the Kuala Lumpur High Court reject the admission of three crucial items as evidence following a trial-within-a-trial. Justice Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah took 10 minutes to reach his decision and ruled that the items - a mineral water bottle, towel and toothbrush - were obtained through unfair means and thus inadmissible as evidence.“These three items and any evidence related to the DNA analysis are to be excluded as part of the evidence.” The prosecution now faces an uphill task to prove a prima facie case as the court decision has broken a vital link in the chain of evidence. The prosecution is expected call three new witnesses, including Dr Razuin Rahimi, the fourth Hospital Kuala Lumpur doctor who was in the team of doctors who examined sodomy complainant Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan. The other witnesses are Anwar's chief of staff Ibrahim Yaakob and investigating officer Supt Jude Blacious Pereira.
9.04am: The court is called into session with Justice Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah presiding. The court calls 22nd witness Ahmad Junaidi Awang, the Road Transport Department registrar. He is to be questioned by DPP Mohd Hanafiah Zakaria.
9.07am: Ahmad Junaidi says he is the record head for Kuala Lumpur.
9.11am: DPP: To whom is the car 'WMK 6' is registered?
Witness: It is registered to Anwar. The car is an Audi. Ahmad says a Perdana V6 automatic is owned by think-tank Malaysian Institute Economic Research (MIER).
9.22am: Ahmad Junaidi says a Toyota Harrier is registered to one Omar Malik. There was another car WNK5251 owned by Chan Wai Hong. The Fiat Ullysses was driven by Saiful. Ahmad also testifies that the owners of other vehicles included Nik Mohd Nik Hassan. DPP ends his questioning. There is no cross-examination.
9.28am: Dr Razuin Rahimi is called into the courtroom. She is the 23rd prosecution witness, and a forensic pathologist at Sungai Buloh hospital.
9.30am: She had previously worked with Hospital Kuala Lumpur (HKL) and Universiti Malaya Medical Centre. She joined HKL as a medical officer in June 2008. Replying to Solicitor-General II Mohd Yusof Zainal Abiden, she says she received a call at 3.30pm on June 28 about a high-profile politician. She was at home at the time. "At 3.30pm, I advised the caller from the hospital to make a police report."9.34am: She was called by Dr Siew Shueu Feng to go to the hospital. "I arrived there at 8.30pm and met Supt Jude Blacious Pereira," she says. Pereira briefed her about the case - that this was an alleged sodomy case involving Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan and Anwar Ibrahim. Saiful, she says, was not present at the briefing, but Pereira introduced him to her later.
9.37am: Saiful is called into the courtroom for identification. Razuin confirms he was the man she met.
9.38am: Razuin says she took down Saiful's medical history. "Saiful related that he had been sodomised a few times and the last time was in Desa Damansara condominium at 3.15pm on June 26, 2008," she said. Karpal wants "a few times" excluded. Judge allows the objection. Razuin says Saiful told him he was not a willing partner.
9.41am: According to Saiful, there was penetration, lubricant was used and his breast was fondled. The interview, she says, lasted 20 minutes and ended around 9pm.
9.43am: Saiful had told the witness that he had objected to performing oral sex.
Says Razuin: "There were two other specialists - Dr Razali Ibrahim and Dr Khairul Nizam Hassan. "There was no difference from what Saiful related to the other doctors, when they asked him again. I was present during the examination. I assisted Dr Siew in writing down history and medical findings."
9.46am: The witness says she did not fill in the details in the pro-forma as Siew said it was not suitable. "I filled in on blank pieces of paper." Razuin is shown by the prosecutor the pro forma form.
9.50am: The witness says she filled page 3, 5, and 6 of the form.
9.51am: Razuin says Saiful had told her that he was unwilling and his body had become tense.
9.52am: According to the witness, Saiful said oral sex was attempted but he refused. Yusof asks about page 5 of the pro forma form: What does it mean by "rectal attempted"? "Saiful said there was anal intercourse, however the rectum is located above the anus, and the word is confusing. At that moment, I do not know whether it reached the rectum." "He ejaculated inside. Penetration, I recorded as 'full' as I got it from Saiful."
9.56am: Razuin says she wrote "employer" to describe the alleged assailant.
Yusof ends his questioning.
9.57am: Karpal cross-examines the witness. Razuin says Pereira took her statements. "The first statement was recorded in January 2010. The second was three weeks ago at my hometown as I was under confinement." 10.01am: The witness denies that rectal sex amounts to sodomy.
Karpal: The rectum is not part of anus?
Razuin: The rectum is below, anus is at the top.
Karpal: To get to the rectum, you have to go through the anus. For sodomy you have to go through the anus?
Razuin: Yes. She says that, medically, the rectum is the lower part and the anus is the top part, so she is unsure whether the penetration did reach the rectum. This is why she wrote 'yes' to 'rectal attempted' in the pro forma form.
10.04am: Razuin says Saiful told her there was bleeding to his anus on the first and second time. Yusof objects, he does not want this part of the evidence. She adds that she saw no bleeding on June 26, 2008 - the day of the medical examination of Saiful.
Karpal finishes his cross-examination.
10.08am: The 24th witness is Ibrahim Yaakob, the chief of staff of Anwar's office. "Saiful was not an employee but a temporary worker. Saiful's duty was that a general office worker. I normally asked him to run errands."
10.10am: Saiful is called into the courtoom and is identified by Ibrahim.10.12am: Ibrahim says that on June 26, 2008, Anwar had a meeting for a luncheon talk on the economy, with one Dr Ariff.
10.13am: He says Anwar called him at his office and told him he left an envelope on the table. Ibrahim was busy and so told Saiful to send the envelope to Anwar.
10.14am: Ibrahim says Saiful resigned by sending an email on June 27. "Saiful told me he cannot performed his duty. He also told me he wants to become a pilot." There is no cross-examination. Yusof asks for short break as next witness is Pereira.
10.31am: Defence lawyer Sankara Nair informs journalists that the trial has been adjourned to tomorrow, due to requests from both the defence and prosecution.
The hearing will resume at 9am.
source:malaysiakini
'Doktor HKL tidak pasti berlaku sodomi ke atas Saiful'
Dr.Razuin kata dia tidak ingat secara tepat bila kenyataannya dirakamkan Pereira namun beliau mengingati beliau ditemui Pereira sebanyak dua kali, pertama sekitar Januari 2011 dan kedua kira-kira tiga minggu lalu dikampungnya.
Seperkara lagi kenapa sebahagian daripada borang proforma diisi oleh pihak polis?
Dakwaan terhadap Anwar berbunyi seperti berikut..."That you on 29 June 2008 between 3.01 - 4.30pm at unit 11-5-1 Desa Damansara Condominium...."
Kalau Dr.Razuin kata dia terima panggilan pada kira-kira 3.30 petang 26 Jun 2008 bererti ada orang lain yang buat panggilan buat report yang Saifool kena sodok pada masa itu. Tak mungkin Saifool yang panggil,kerana waktu itu dia dalam alam khayalan!! Sedangkan pertuduhan terhadap Anwar sebut "bahawa anda antara pukul 3.01-4.30 petang pada 26 Jun 2008....."
Bolehkah Saifool yang sedang dibalun sempat ambil handset dan call Dr.Razuin atau polis? Ini bererti peristewa ini sememang sudah dirancang terlebih dahulu. Mungkin orang yang panggil itu adalah pegawai polis yang merancang konspirasi tersebut.
Nyata direktor drama ini orang yang bengong.....
cheers.
No comments:
Post a Comment