Who is bias BN or PR speakers.....

An Umno leader is wringing his hands over what he feels is speaker bias in legislative assemblies of Pakatan Rakyat-ruled states. Seberang Jaya assemblyperson Arif Shah said their lack of even-handed treatment at times had stirred "dissatisfaction and disappointment' among opposition representatives.

He pointed out that when the speaker acted in an unjust manner, assemblypersons have no means to retaliate as the former has "absolute" authority during proceedings.

"Sometime he punishes us wrongly; when the opposition raises a question to the state executive committee member at the assembly sittings, the replies are not relevant but the speaker simply says 'sit down'," he complained.

He also griped during a dialogue session at the Penang assembly yesterday that backbenchers (from the ruling party) take advantage of the standing orders to prevent them from speaking. Arif said such a situation only happened

after March 2008, unlike the times when the Barisan Nasional was ruling the state.

Lets see(video) whether the Speaker of Parliament was acting in a just or unjust manner......

Seorang pemimpin Umno mendakwa bahawa speaker Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) yang diperintah oleh Pakatan Rakyat bersikap berat sebelah terhadap wakil rakyat pembangkang.

ADUN Seberang Jaya Datuk Arif Shah berkata layanan tidak adil itu telah menimbulkan rasa "tidak puashati" di kalangan wakil rakyat pembangkang. Menurutnya, apabila speaker bersikap tidak adil, maka wakil rakyat tidak dapat membantah kerana speaker mempunyai kuasa "mutlak" di dewan.

"Kadang-kadang beliau menghukum kita secara salah; apabila pihak pembangkang mengajukan pertanyaan kepada exco negeri di sidang DUN, jawapannya tidak relevan tetapi speaker hanya kata 'duduk'," tambahnya.

Tapi bila ahli2 BN mengambil tindakan untuk mengheret keluar macam anjing Speaker PR yang sah dan melantik seorang speaker(grafik diatas) haram serta MB lantikan mahkamah Adun2 BN kita buat diam saja.....

cheers.