Mahkamah Persekutuan menjadi perhatian hari ini apabila ia akan memutuskan kes berprofil tinggi membabitkan pembunuhan warganegara Mongolia Altantuya Shaariibuu.
Mahkamah itu akan mendengar rayuan pendakwa terhadap pembebasan dua anggota Unit Tindakan Khas polis, Cif Inspektor Azilah Hadri dan Koperal Sirul Azhar Umar terhadap pertuduhan membunuh Altantuya.
Pada 23 Ogos tahun lalu, Mahkamah Rayuan membebaskan Azilah dan Sirul Azhar daripada pertuduhan membunuh selepas sebulat suara membenarkan rayuan mereka dan meminda sabitan hukuman mati yang diputuskan Mahkamah Tinggi Shah Alam pada 2009.
Mereka didapati bersalah membunuh Altantuya, 28, di Mukim Bukit Raja di Shah Alam antara 10 malam 19 Oktober dan 1 pagi 20 Oktober 2006.
Mahkamah Rayuan, dalam penghakiman 47 muka surat, menegaskan bahawa keterangan ikut keadaan yang dikemukakan pendakwaan tidak mencukupi untuk mengekalkan keputusan bersalah kedua-dua anggota polis itu.
Kesalahan mereka dilaporkan tidak dibuktikan dengan memuaskan, "oleh itu mahkamah terpaksa memberi mereka faedah kesangsian".
Cif Inspektor Azilah Hadri yang dibebaskan daripada tuduhan membunuh wanita warga Mongolia, Altantuya Shaariibuu, adalah individu yang membawa polis ke tempat kejadian di dalam hutan di Puncak Alam, Mahkamah Persekutuan diberitahu pada Isnin.
Timbalan Peguam Cara Negara II Datuk Tun Abdul Majid Tun Hamzah berkata Azilah juga yang membawa kepada penemuan tulang si mati sebelum Koperal Sirul Azhar Umar tiba di tempat kejadian bersama pasukan polis lain.
“Polis hanya mengetahui lokasi secara umum dan bukan lokasi khusus tempat kejadian.
“Adalah mustahil bagi polis untuk mengesan kawasan itu yang terletak di atas bukit di dalam hutan, lokasinya tidak mudah dikesan, melainkan mereka mempunyai maklumat,” hujah Tun Abdul Majid pada pendengaran rayuan pendakwa terhadap pembebasan kedua-dua anggota polis berkenaan.
Tun Abdul Majid juga berkata berdasarkan keterangan anggota polis semasa perbicaraan di Mahkamah Tinggi, saksi itu berkata sebaik tiba di hutan, Azilah memberitahunya lokasi kejadian itu dan menceritakan bagaimana Altantuya ditembak dan bahan letupan digunakan terhadapnya.
“Di tempat kejadian pihak polis menemui tulang manusia yang kemudiannya terbukti milik si mati,” hujah Tun Abdul Majid di hadapan lima anggota panel diketuai Ketua Hakim Negara Tun Arifin Zakaria.
Panel itu turut dianggotai Hakim Besar Sabah dan Sarawak Tan Sri Richard Malanjum serta Hakim Mahkamah Persekutuan iaitu Tan Sri Abdull Hamid Embong, Tan Sri Suriyadi Halim Omar dan Tan Sri Ahmad Maarop.
Pada 23 Ogos tahun lepas, Mahkamah Rayuan membebaskan Azilah dan Sirul Azhar daripada pertuduhan membunuh selepas sebulat suara membenarkan rayuan mereka dan meminda sabitan hukuman mati yang diputuskan Mahkamah Tinggi Shah Alam pada 2009.
Mereka didapati bersalah membunuh Altantuya, 28, di Mukim Bukit Raja di Shah Alam antara 10 malam 19 Okt dan 1 pagi 20 Okt 2006.
Mahkamah Rayuan, dalam penghakiman 47 muka surat, menegaskan bahawa keterangan ikut keadaan yang dikemukakan pendakwaan tidak mencukupi untuk mengekalkan keputusan bersalah kedua-dua anggota polis itu.
Kesalahan mereka tidak dibuktikan dengan memuaskan, “oleh itu, mahkamah terpaksa memberi mereka faedah kesangsian”.
Pendakwaan memfailkan petisyen rayuan pada 3 Jan tahun ini, menyenaraikan enam sebab panel tiga hakim Mahkamah Rayuan telah terkhilaf, dalam undang-undang dan fakta, untuk membenarkan kedua-dua anggota polis itu terlepas daripada tali gantung.
Bekas penganalisis politik Abdul Razak Baginda, 50, yang pada mulanya didakwa bersubahat dengan mereka, dibebaskan oleh Mahkamah Tinggi pada 31 Okt 2008 selepas mendapati pendakwaan gagal mewujudkan kes prima facie terhadapnya.– Bernama
Azilah brought police to the crime scene,led to the discovery of Altantuya's bones...
Deputy Solicitor-General II, Datuk Tun Abdul Majid Tun Hamzah said Azilah led to the discovery of the deceased’s bones before Corporal Sirul Azhar Umar arrived at the crime scene with another police team.
“The police only knew a general location and not specific location of the place. It is impossible for the police to locate the place which was on the top of a hill in the jungle. The spot could not be easily located, unless they had information,” he submitted at the hearing of the prosecution’s appeal against the acquittal of the two policemen.
Tun Abdul Majid said that based on the evidence by a policeman during the trial at the High Court, the witness had said that when reaching the jungle, Azilah had told him that this was the place and showed the incident where Altantuya was shot and explosives were used on her.
“At the crime scene, the police found human remains, subsequently proven to be that of the deceased,” he argued before a five-member panel led by Chief Justice Tun Arifin Zakaria.
The other judges were Chief Judge of Sabah and Sarawak Tan Sri Richard Malanjum, Federal Court judges Tan Sri Abdull Hamid Embong, Tan Sri Suriyadi Halim Omar and Tan Sri Ahmad Maarop.
The Court of Appeal had on Aug 23, last year, freed Azilah, 37, and Sirul Azhar, 42, on the murder charge after unanimously allowing their appeals, hence, overturning their conviction and death sentence imposed by the Shah Alam High Court in 2009, which found them guilty of murdering Altantuya, 28.
They were charged with murdering the woman at Mukim Bukit Raja in Shah Alam between 10pm on Oct 19 and 1am, the following day in 2006.
The Court of Appeal in its judgment held that circumstantial evidence adduced by the prosecution was insufficient to sustain the finding of the duo’s guilt and their guilt had not been satisfactorily proven, “thus, the court was constrained to give them the benefit of the doubt”.
The prosecution filed its petition of appeal on Jan 3, this year, listing six reasons why the three-member Court of Appeal bench was wrong in law and facts to allow the two policemen to escape the gallows.
Former political analyst Abdul Razak Baginda, 50, who was initially charged with abetting Azilah and Sirul Azhar, was acquitted by the High Court on Oct 31, 2008 after it (the high court) held that the prosecution failed to establish a prima facie case against him.
Tun Abdul Majid submitted that the Court of Appeal had erred in law when rejecting the evidence under Section 27 of the Evidence Act 1950 on the discovery of jewelleries belonging to Altantuya in Sirul Azhar’s jacket, by relying on the sequence of events which the court claimed showed contradictions.
“Whatever the sequence of events, the fact remained that some jewelleries proved as belonging to the deceased, were found in the second respondent’s (Sirul Azhar) jacket at his house in Kota Damansara,” he said, adding that there was no denial from Sirul Azhar that the jacket belonged to him.
He said the DNA proven to belong to Altantuya was found inside the jacket, and noted how the items were found in Sirul Azhar’s possession.
Tun Abdul Majid argued that there was no evidence that Sirul Azhar was framed as the prosecution had called all relevant witnesses during the trial.
On the issue of a pair of slippers found in Sirul Azhar’s car, he said the slippers did not belong to him and they were also not his size.
“There is no evidence to show how the slippers were in the car, but there was blood found on them…had dried up. So, how the blood was found on the slippers? It must be from the scene,” said Tun Abdul Majid.
On another point, he said that according to the telco database, Azilah was at the crime scene in Puncak Alam, at the material time of the incident.
He noted that Azilah could never have been at Wangsa Maju or Taman Melati, or Batu Caves, not even in Jalan Duta before proceeding to Bukit Aman at the material time as he had alleged in his alibi.
Furthermore, Tun Abdul Majid submitted that Azilah had also failed to adduce any witness for his alibi when called for defence at the end of the prosecution’s case.
Asked by Arifin how the telco database led to a finding that at the time, Azilah was at the crime scene, Tun Abdul Majid replied, a particular telephone broadcasting station could detect where a person making a call was located.
“The call logs of the police officers (respondents) have been verified by the telco operators who had printed out the data and signed it, saying it is verified,” he said.
He stressed that there was no tampering of handphone data on the respondent (Azilah).
At the outset, when reading briefly the background facts of the case, Tun Abdul Majid said according to a witness during the trial, Altantuya was brought to (the federal police headquarters in) Bukit Aman, and the deceased was last seen entering a car driven by Sirul Azhar.
He said on Oct 20, 2006, the woman was reported missing and investigations led to the arrest of both policemen (Azilah and Sirul Azhar), together with Razak Baginda.
On Nov 6, in the same year, fragments of human bone, hair and tissues were discovered in the forest area in Puncak Alam and the DNA analysis proved the remains to be that of the deceased.
He said according to the forensic pathologist, the cause of death was “probable blast-related injuries”.
The hearing continues Tuesday. - Bernama
Teresa Kok yang dilarang masuk Sarawak kini dapat pas khas untuk ke Sarawak selama 7 hari saja...Sarawak ni wilayah Malaysia ke...
Lawak dunia bola Melayu UMNO...
Jam 12.00 pagi 24/6/2014
Jam 4.00 pagi 24/6/2014
cheers.
No comments:
Post a Comment